President Donald Trump may be starting to feel lonely without his tech buddies around. First Jensen Huang had his spectacular fall from Nvidia, and in an even crueler cut, Elon Musk is acting like he and Trump never had the tempestuous bromance we all suffered through for the last two years.
“I’m not MAGA,” Musk said, calling in to The New York Times’ DealBook Summit on Wednesday. “I’m not sure what MAGA means, but if that means sort of blind adherence to a set of policies by the Republican Party, then I certainly don’t have that.”
What about all those times he appeared in MAGA hats, or joined Trump in 2024 at campaign rallies, or proclaimed, “I’m not just MAGA, I’m dark MAGA!”
What about all those times he appeared in MAGA hats, or joined Trump in 2024 at campaign rallies, or proclaimed, “I’m not just MAGA, I’m dark MAGA!” (whatever that means), or joined the Trump administration to rampage through the federal government with catastrophic results? Are we supposed to forget all that?
Perhaps when you own your own social media platform, make insane predictions people somehow take seriously despite the fact that they seem to never come true and became a trillionaire by pumping wildly inflated stock prices, you think the rubes will buy anything you tell them.
But here’s the irony: It’s true there is a large group of Americans who have been quite willing to believe even the most bizarre and obviously false rewriting of history. But they’re precisely the ones from whom Musk is now trying to distance himself.
To be a true devotee of Trump, after all, requires the ability to adopt new deranged and provably false beliefs at a moment’s notice, should Trump tell you to do so.
The 2020 election? Stolen. The 2024 election that Trump won by 1.5 percentage points? A huge landslide. The violent Jan. 6 insurrection? A “day of love.” The Covid-19 pandemic that killed over 1.2 million Americans? The real tragedy was the measures taken to prevent the spread of the virus. Any and every problem the Trump administration has failed to solve? Joe Biden’s fault.
But even the most gullible Trump fan won’t be inclined to believe that Musk was never MAGA in the first place. And the rest of us are even less than inclined to welcome him back to the population of the sane.
Trump, uncharacteristically, appeared to take Musk’s comments with surprising equanimity.
“There are lots of definitions out there,” Trump told NBC News. “MAGA, to me, means something very specific, and when people veer from it, they don’t do very well.”
It’s possible to read that as a warning, or just as a kind of self-soothing; Trump reassuring himself that he and his movement are still popular. Because after the midterm elections, it’s pretty obvious that sticking too close to MAGA, not veering from it, is what causes one to not “do very well.”
Musk found that out the hard way, having just spent nearly half a billion dollars in support of GOP candidates in a midterm cycle that Republicans overwhelmingly lost. He told the Times, “I feel pretty foolish about having spent so much money and not seeing much for it.”
After the midterm elections, it’s pretty obvious that sticking too close to MAGA, not veering from it, is what causes one to not “do very well.”
But don’t expect Democrats to welcome him back with open arms. While he had much to gain from his alliance with Trump — a steady supply of government contracts and the quashing of investigations into his companies, among other things — the Trump-Musk bond was built on more than self-interest. Musk was and remains MAGA in the deepest sense.
It’s true that the foundation of MAGA is its cult-like devotion to Trump himself. But the movement does have a discernible worldview, at least on a few issues. Primary among them is immigration, where the movement is intensely nativist, opposed to immigration and often nakedly racist.
So are the many statements of Musk. Even if one wants to be generous to him about that salute, he posts relentlessly on X about race, railing against non-white immigration to America and Europe and toying with eugenicist ideas. He uses his platform to promote far-right parties around the globe. These are not the actions of a clear-eyed capitalist; if anything, they do significant harm to his businesses. We can therefore only surmise that they represent Musk’s sincere beliefs.
No one is going to believe Musk if he tries to reinvent himself as nonpolitical in response to the new realities of power in Washington. Democrats certainly don’t; they are preparing multiple investigations into his billions of dollars in federal contracts, the wreckage he caused with the Department of Government Efficiency and whether he throttled the Starlink internet service on which the Ukrainian military relies. Those are all legitimate lines of inquiry, and if there’s a bit of revenge mixed in? Musk can only blame himself.
Meanwhile, Trump isn’t willing to let Musk go.
“I helped Elon a lot in my first term,” he said this week, adding that “a lot of people don’t know that, you wouldn’t probably have Elon today” — if it weren’t for him, of course.
Which isn’t quite true, but it’s a reminder of what the two men have in common: oversized egos, an ability to seize almost limitless attention in the social media age, ugly ideological beliefs and a faith that they can convince the masses of almost anything. They may not always get along, but they will forever be tied together.